JOELFORRESTER.COM

      REVIEWS

Joel Forrester,    EMBRACING CHANGE IN REAL TIME ("Master Class" for Keyboard School Woodshed – Downbeat, Sept. 2011)

I believe that every living human has a personal sense of time, a signature as unique as any of the more usual means of individual authentication. What singles out musicians and dancers is our developed ability to express this sense.

If you're reading this, you're likely a musician. I am, too. As musicians, our lives are important to the species as a whole. Don't let anyone tell you that you're marginal; don't allow public indifference to prey on you, don't let commerce trivialize your calling. I repeat: Our lives are important. Don't let your daily struggles erode this certainty.

This is important, because without individual expression of time, time would become terminally confused with its measurement: the clock would rule the planet. It already does for those who don't dance or play. For the unlistening ear, music is at best a trip: a moment outside of time, blessed recreation. For us, music is our lives: We live time – a wild gift, a serious responsibility. Time is our language.

Your personal sense of time exists both prior to your experience in life and accompanies you every step of the way – it has everything to do with your choices, your destiny. When your chops are together on your instrument and you voice is truly your own, your temporal distinction can help any listener whose personality is submerged in patterns of authority, whose sense of herself depends on what others tell her. What people think they want is recreation, entertainment; but what they really both need and desire is to be themselves. We can help with that.

It might take years for you to find your voice. That can't bother you. The searching is the finding. Everybody starts out imitating someone else. The point is never to give in to the allure that surrounds imitating yourself. Forget it – that's how you sounded yesterday. That's another reason to take yourself seriously as a musician: You operate in a medium that embodies change. People need encouragement to change. We certainly can help them with that, too

. But there are additional depths to be sounded. Living as a musician is a gift; our souls know a freedom not granted to others; and the most important thing we can offer, in return, has to do with memory.

There is more to memory than information retrieval. The hardest thing to remember is the fact that your life is limited. I believe that all definition arises out of an awareness that our lives will end. Death defines us, and we learn from that. But we also pass much of the waking day hiding from this awareness. Novelist Anthony Powell once had a character title his autobiography Camel Ride to the Tomb, something he once saw as a kid on a sign outside an Egyptian airport. I played with drummer Denis Charles for 25 years; I once warned him about the temporary nature of a weekly gig we had; he answered with an open-arm gesture meant to include all creation and said, "Man, this whole scene is temporary!"

A musician focuses her memory on the present. Her memory allows her to make a moment of that present. That moment can be shared y all who hear what she plays. Life is every bit as temporary, but we are no longer on the "camel ride". The musical moment involves a tacit acceptance of death; it does not hide from death by killing time. Music needs time to breathe.

My guide here has always been Austrian musicologist Victor Zuckerandl, who described hearing the succeeding tones in a melody as a master of "freedom in prospect, necessity in retrospect." This involves memory as a dynamic process. Again, that's functionally obvious to a musician; he needn't think about it. And it's always been important.

But never more so than today, when we are inundated with information, most of it visual. At the same time, there is a consensus that our species must soon go through a change in order to survive; and our most honest critics say it is the inability to deal with death that holds us back. All the more important, then, for those gifted with music to live "melodic" lives; that is: open to the moment, if only momentarily.

Any musician knows that there's more to existence than the visual world, more to memory than data. The eye may justly be considered the window to the soul, but the ear is the portal.

We are heralds, we musicians. We can help humankind make the next big change. And just by being ourselves.



George Kanzler,    Down The Road (New York City Jazz Record, Sept. 2011)

"Art for art's sake" is a nice homily more honored in the breach than in the observance. What jazz musicians do is tangled up in many constraints and competing intentions. They consider commercial popularity, as Miles did in embracing Michael Jackson's "Human Nature", or temper artistic ambitions with popular sweetenings, as Creed Taylor's productions did. And in today's capitalist top-heavy age, patronage – that economic impetus of Renaissance art - is becoming more important and more influential on jazz musicians.

This album is as much the brainchild of "biotechnology entrepreneur and new music philanthropist" Glenn Cornett (who presumably financed it) as it is of pianist Joel Forrester. In fact, the press release for it credits Cornett with not only handpicking the band but the "musical approach was suggested by [him] and is inspired by his penchant for progressive rock." It's an odd fit for a jazzman best known as co-leader of The Microscopic Septet and leader of People Like Us to tackle an often grandiose style identified with the likes of King Crimson and Yes. Forrester's ambivalence - also evident in the finished product - is revealed in his notes with the album: "I filled a few perfervid weeks in Brittany and Paris furiously writing music that didn't swing. I mistakenly imagined that the great bass player Jean Bardy was into the Chapman Stick; and when he wasn't, got him to play electric bass. I encouraged my regular drummer in France, Richard Portier, a master of subtlety and tact, to play LOUDER than his wont. Would that do?...I also suggested to Glenn that we call the band PFROG, seeking to capture in name what eluded me in deed."

The results are equivocal, neither truly a jazz take on prog rock nor a prog rock-inspired jazz album, yet the tension between the patron's wishes and leader's jazz inclinations yield some fresh and surprising music nonetheless. "Second Nature", done by the full quintet with piano-electric bass-drums joined by electric guitarist Manu Codjia (fully conversant in jazz-rock vocabulary) and baritone saxophonist Alex Hamlin (whose legato style and vibrato suggest an amped-up piccolo bass) features a patterned rhythm and stairclimbing melody redolent of King Crimson. On other tracks, Forrester employs such prog rock tropes as mixed time signatures and classical allusions like minuet ("Skirmish") and pointillism ("Who Ever Knew") and even includes a suite-like track suggesting etudes featuring a different instrument in each section ("Vortex"). Forrester sticks to acoustic piano and the tracks closest to the swing he professes to eschew are the trio tracks, or trio sections of others by the quintet. And repeated listening will reveal a whimsy and wit in the conception that might elude a first go-around – it did for me.



Jennifer Odell,JOEL FORRESTER: SILENTS' BUZZ (Feature in Downbeat, Sept. 2010)
As a precariously perched Buster Keaton see-sawed back and forth on a ladder tipped sideways over a fence, a cluster of cops shuffled beneath him, shaking their batons and gesturing furiously. Beneath the flickering grey and white light of the silent film Cops was a solo piano, its player, Joel Forrester, using a combination of stride and bop elements and his own sense of comedy to propel each character's actions into three-dimensional swing as he accompanied the film.

In New York, which Forrester has called home since the early '70s, the 64-year-old pianist's name is synonymous with the horn-heavy Microscopic Septet he co-led from 1980-1992 with Philip Johnston. A prolific composer, his estimated 1,200 works of music include "Fresh Air", the theme of Terry Gross' National Public Radio show. While Forrester and Johnston shared composing duties in the band, the pianist's solo work is similarly accessible and experimental, the latter quality coming in part from his study with Thelonious Monk, whom he credits with having given his music a "searching quality, harmonically".

But in Paris, Forrester's reputation hinges on his solo performances set to silent films. He's played such programs at the Louvre, the Pompidou Center and the Musee D'Orsay, and on one warm evening this spring, he held court in New York's Gershwin Hotel, where his understated conversational humor matched his ability to tell a funny story through music.

Case in point: "Lunacy", Forrester's opening number. From the top, a dirge-like cadence carried the lower register, punctuated every few bars with a purposeful plunk from Forrester's right hand. The interplay evoked a teasing refrain; it could conjure a bird knocking the hat off Charlie Chaplin's head in time to the tune. As the melody developed, listeners' imaginations began to do for the compositions that Keaton would do in the second half of the show.

"That was the idea," Forrester said a week later. He explained that introducing the concept of jazz and silent film with the music alone opens the listeners' minds to the concept. "If I'm doing my job, people forget that I'm playing and are just into the dual experience."

But when he performed music to Keaton's Cops, a Tim Burton-esque piece called "The Mascot", and a dark comedy called Haunted Spooks, the sound and visual elements of the experience were seamless. Even Forrester's musical comedy is in line with what he's learned from studying the cinema. Take Harold Lloyd, the star of Haunted Spooks.

"[Lloyd] sets up his visual jokes … in advance," Forrester said. "Seemingly random actions end up causing the thing that's really funny."

He points to a series of comedic scenes based on the protagonist's ineffectual suicide attempts. "It's a technique of building a climax that's in itself deflationary," he said. "I got that from him and use it all the time in music."

Forrester's path to "the world's leading accompanist to silent film," as the Paris Free Voice has dubbed him, has been both illustrious – he composed music for many of Andy Warhol's early movies – and pragmatic: Two decades ago, he played 11-hour shifts at a Manhattan silent movie house. But these days, he's found a steady groove, performing music to film, leading his two bands and occasionally reuniting with the Micros, who recorded an album of Monk's music this spring with the release date to be determined.

The pianist is currently working on a musical theater memoir of his life, to be completed and staged in Paris. Only there, he says, can he really duck out of "that flow" of New York rhythms that presses him to keep gigging with his various bands.

"My music always starts life as a solo piano piece, then gets programmed to its proper-size group," Forrester said. "But when I play solo, I lose myself, and that's really important. It's very much a solitary buzz, me and these images."


Joel Roberts,    January 2005 (A longtime contributor to www.allaboutjazz.com, Joel Roberts is by day the politics producer at CBSNews.com)
Joel Forrester has had a fascinating career. He studied piano with Thelonious Monk, scored early Andy Warhol films, wrote the theme for the popular NPR show Fresh Air , accompanied silent films at the Louvre, and spent years as a principal member of the fondly remembered Microscopic Septet..

He's also been the driving force between one of the liveliest bands in town, People Like Us, a quartet devoted to Forrester's quirkily intelligent compositions. Ever Wonder Why collects eleven new and not-so-new Forrester tunes, a typically eclectic assortment that highlights his winning mix of erudition and humor. For those familiar with Forrester, it's no surprise to find a novelty like “Bebop Cowpoke” alongside dedications to Mary Lou Williams and overlooked hard bop alto saxophonist Frank Strozier, as well as an earnest vocal choir reflecting on Sept. 11th.

As a pianist, Forrester is heavily influenced by Monk, along with Monk's stride and boogie-woogie predecessors. His primary foil is the marvelous baritone saxophonist Claire Daly, who shares his absurdist sensibility as well as his deep knowledge of the jazz vernacular. The fine rhythm section includes Dave Hofstra on bass and Ronnie Williams on drums, filling the chair held by the late, great Denis Charles.

This is serious music played by serious musicians who don't take themselves too seriously.


THE NEW YORKER,    November 2000
Joel Forrester, the maestro of the wonderful People Like Us ensemble, remains a most agreeably eclectic pianist, and among the most undervalued of jazz composers.  The sheer pleasure he brings to a panoply of styles, and to the individual way he absorbs them all, denotes comfort rather than scholarly erudition.  He's enthroned here at the keyboard Monday nights in November.


THE NEW YORKER,   June 1999
IT'S A MICROSCOPIC WORLD - Some of the most distinctive jazz of the past few years can be directly traced to the demise of the Microscopic Septet.  When that singular ensemble - which was acclaimed for its deft saxophone writing and daft sense of humor - split after eleven years, in 1992, its co-leaders, saxophonist Philip Johnston and pianist Joel Forrester, formed topflight bands of their own.

Joel Forrester leads People Like Us, a quartet that just released its third album, Believe It, which was recorded in 1997.  This piano virtuoso calls on his own set of jazz heroes - individualists like Thelonious Monk, Gerry Mulligan, James P. Johnson, and Herbie Nichols - to inform his writing and improvising.  Forrester's simpatico bandmadets - baritone saxophonist Claire Daly, drummer Denis Charles (a brilliant player who died unexplectedly last year), and bassist Dave Hofstra (who also plays in Johnston's band) - genereate an infectious rhythmic bounce that complements the formal grace of the leader's indelible tunes.  Subtle levity is still at the heart of much of Forrester and Johnston's music; thankfully, both bandleaders have abandoned the overt humor that sometimes obscured the brilliance and craftsmanship of the septet.

The Microscopic influence can also be heard on two other recent disks.  Claire Daly's Swing Low, a melodious set of imaginatively arranged standards and offbeat tunes, establishes her as our most gifted mainstream baritone saxiphonist; Joel Forrester and the Illustrious Others: Pre-Microscopic Music Circa 1980 1980 shows that Forrester and Johnston (who appears throughout) were, in their wayward youth, just as whip-smart and eager to follow roads less travelled as they are today.


JAZZIZ ,   February 1999
A little looser, yet quite similar is In Heaven by People Like Us.  The music's singularity stems from pianist-leader Joel Forrester's distinctive tunes.  They should properly be called compositions - they're elaborate and rigorous enought to be deemed so.  But there's an intrinsic congeniality to Forrester's writing for this band.  It makes thoughtful, progressive improvising seem like the most joyous task around.
Dave Hofstra's animated bass is also part of this band, which includes the late Denis Charles on drums, and the baritone saxist Claire Daly.  From the gleefully bent salutation, "Straight Ahead", to thinfectious "Make Mine Music", the band gives the tunes a daft élan that suggests advanced ideas have many ways to avoid stuffiness.


THE PARIS FREE VOICE,   May 1996
Pianist, composer and arranger Joel Forrester is the kind of man who can turn a tune - or a jury - on its head.  Performing at Carnegie Hall for the Young Concert Artists awards, Forrester split the jury.  Whatever he's about, it's not compromise.  Maybe he got that from the times when he'd drop by and play for Thelonious Monk shortly before the great man's death.  Fully dressed, Monk would lie on top of his bead, listening to Forrester's playing in the adjoining room.  "It was the most acute form of musical criticism I've ever received," recalls Forrester.  "If he didn't like what I was playing, he'd just stretch his foot off the bed and kick the door shut!"

Monk's rigorous ears have served Forrester well.  Densely textured yet rippling with panache, his piano playing is a joy to hear.  Regarded as the world's finest improvisational accompanist to silent films, Forrester is in town for a weeklong gig at the Louvre, where he'll be providing live piano accompaniment to a series of silent films of the them of exotica.  And on May12 he'll be at L'Arganier jazz club with his trio, featuring John Betxh on drums and François Moutier on bass, paying homage to the great New Orleans pianist Meade Lux Lewis as part of the club's Sunday night tributes.  Forrester then plays solo piano at the appealing and atmospheric Pouchla bar north of Les Halles, May 17.


Chuck Berg, "Joel Forrester and the Illustrious Others"
Though hardly a household name, pianist Joel Forrester is nonetheless "known" to fans of Terry Gross' "Fresh Air" via his mind-tickling theme for the National Public Radio staple. Thanks to Koch, which has released four previous Forrester projects, the iconoclastic pianist-composer and his Microscopic cohorts are beginning to take on an identity beyond the ether-wafted emanations of NPR. Here, however, we're taken back to Forrester's "Pre-Microscopic Music Circa 1980", as the subtitle puts it.

The varied menu serves up tasty dollops of grit-cum-whimsy. There are solo forays by Forrester, such has "Dr. Real" with tips-of-the-hat to both Erik Satie and Bud Powell. Among the septet tracks is the mini-epic, "Until Tomorrow", in which a haunting hymn intoned by vocalist Shelley Hirsch explodes into a galvanizing Latin romp with impressive wailing by soprano saxist Philip Johnston, trumpeter Tony Salazar and tenorist Lucky Ennett. Anchoring with aplomb are bassist Dave Hofstra and drummer Denis Charles. And Joel Forrester? A name worth remembering!


John Barrett, Jr.Believe It (Review – Jazz Imrpov, Dec. 1999)
This is strangely different. While the piano goes odd directions, the bari chugs on like a 1920s novelty, oblivious to the modernity. The title theme floats in with bebop cool; come the solo Joel Forrester starts to sound aloof. A pleasant lounge turns intellectual, with a fast quote of "Well, You Needn't". Claire Daly rushes in, honking with abandon; she trades with Denis Charles, who stays in march cadence! Then Claire solos, and her surge meets sour bleeps from Forrester. These disparate elements somehow jell; it's an off-center feel close to Monk, and oddly familiar.

"Flip Flop" is an angular blues, Forrester responding to his own calls. Mostly it's Dave Hofstra, walking fat as Joel interjects. The piano is everywhere: the mood of Monk, phrases of Duke, and a moment of Cecil Taylor! "Think…Pretty" goes deep in Thelonious country: the theme is tender like "Crespescule", and the comps are "Friday the 13th". Claire rocks warmly, and reaches the depths in a lovely groan. "This is what makes sense to me," she said about the bari; her solo makes perfect sense. This was an outtake from their last album, In Heaven; this version takes you there!

"White Blues" is the deepest depression: Joel takes the bass line with a limp, and Claire's tone is menacing. Her solo is part Webster, part foghorn – with the warmth you find on her album Swing Low. Hofstra steps lightly, accented by twinkling stars (Joel, way up high). Forrester is languid: a soft lazy stretch, minus the frenzy he sometimes gets bogged in. "Baker Bounce" is all Claire: a happy line and nice poppin'. She wanders up into tenor range, romping like Adams while Joel nails little notes. He keeps it simple, with gentle lines rolling sunny. His best turn, if not his best tune. (That would be "Pretty".) We leave with another take of "Believe It". This one's rough but has its charms. Joel is much warmer, a bright scamper through steady cymbals. Daly starts tentative, but unleashes a torrent – broad strokes and a lot of power. Everything shines, and Charles has his best fills. You see why it didn't lead off, but you also see why they included it.

It's a nice blend of new and old' Forrester has an intriguing sound, though I prefer him in straight-ahead mode. His tunes are nice, and the group very unified, which sadly is no more. (Denis Charles passed away last year.) This makes a memorial, but far from a sad one.


Scott Yanow, 1) Joel Forrester & The Illustrious Others
                      2) Believe It (Review – Cadence, Sept. 1999)

(1) Features pianist Joel Forrester near the beginning of his career while (2) is from the present day. It is always enjoyable to hear adventurous musicians do their take on bebop; much more fun than listening to revivalists try to recreate the excitement of the past.

(1) has the feel of a well-organized rehearsal and contains more than its share of colorful moments. Forrester takes "Getting Started" (which is supposed to be reminiscent of Charles Mingus' playing on "I Can't Get It Started" but is actually closer to Bud Powell on "All God's Chillun") as a trio romp with bassist Dewey Dellay and drummer Richard Dworkin. Although essentially bop, there are spots where Forrester makes it obvious that it was 1980 and not 1950. Both "Mary" (a spontaneous improvisation on a theme that Forrester had been toying with for a decade) and "Dr. Real" (a bizarre stride piece) are piano solos. The one non-Forrester original, Thelonious Monk's "Work", is played by a quartet with soprano-saxophonist Phillip Johnston, bassist Dave Hofstra and drummer Dennis Charles. Singer Shelley Hirsch joins the group on the nutty 5/4 piece "He Do"; here expert wordless vocalizing (which is often heard in the ensembles) is also in evidence on the other four pieces which utilize a septet (with Hofstra and Charles). Of those numbers, "Lt. Cossowary" is an odd boogie-woogie piece, "Until Tomorrow" is a Latin number, "Portrait Of Denis Charles" gives the veteran some breaks and "A Clean Break" is a brief closing theme. Although there are some good moments from the horns, the stars of this early effort are Joel Forrester and Shelley Hirsch.

Seventeen years later and on (2) Joel Forrester's piano playing is not all that different than on (1) except for having grown in maturity and strength. On this set, all seven numbers are by the leader but many could pass as mildly eccentric 1950's standards, with a couple sounding Monkish. Claire Daly's strong baritone playing is a little reminiscent of Lars Gullin's, heavier than Mulligan's but a lot lighter tonewise that Pepper Adams; in any case she is a fine bop-based improviser. Bassist Dave Hofstra was still with Forrester, offering supportive lines while drummer Denis Charles, on one of his last sessions (nine months before his death) is both subtle and powerful, constantly creative. The overall effect is quite good-natured and occasionally humorous, showing that modern jazz can be joyful.

(1) gets the edge due to its variety but (2) is worth acquiring also.


Chuck Berg,Joel Forrester and the Illustrious Others
Though hardly a household name, pianist Joel Forrester is nonetheless "known" to fans of Terry Gross' "Fresh Air" via his mind-tickling theme for the National Public Radio staple. Thanks to Koch, which has released four previous Forrester projects, the iconoclastic pianist-composer and his Microscopic cohorts are beginning to take on an identity beyond the ether-wafted emanations of NPR. Here, however, we're taken back to Forrester's "Pre-Microscopic Music Circa 1980", as the subtitle puts it.

The varied menu serves up tasty dollops of grit-cum-whimsy. There are solo forays by Forrester, such has "Dr. Real" with tips-of-the-hat to both Erik Satie and Bud Powell. Among the septet tracks is the mini-epic, "Until Tomorrow", in which a haunting hymn intoned by vocalist Shelley Hirsch explodes into a galvanizing Latin romp with impressive wailing by soprano saxist Philip Johnston, trumpeter Tony Salazar and tenorist Lucky Ennett. Anchoring with aplomb are bassist Dave Hofstra and drummer Denis Charles. And Joel Forrester? A name worth remembering!


Andrew Bartlett,(Review on Amazon.com, June 1999)
Pianist and composer Joel Forrester's music is better known than you might think. Forrester's coup de grace is the theme for Terry Gross's Fresh Air, the National Public Radio show that roves through arts and culture on a daily basis. And while you can get Forrester's solo piano take on the theme on his Stop the Music, with Believe It you get Forrester's creative People Like Us quartet. Claire Daly's baritone sax is one of the band's hallmarks, with her slippery phrasing and clear fondness for the horn's low-end blurs.

Forrester's People Like Us tunes are mostly midtempo, swinging crossroads, where bebop and its predecessors make fruitful bedfellows on a rhythmic mattress of Denis Charles's drums and Dave Hofstra's bass. This is playful music, entertaining and improvisationally interesting, with Forrester integrating a bounce learned from hard bop and a style of composition that sounds touched with Herb Nichols's delightful genius for segues and odd interludes. As a companion to Believe It, more daring listeners might want to try Forrester's early works, predating his tenure in Phillip Johnston's Microscopic Septet, on the aptly titled Pre-Microscopic Music Circa 198


                   Believe It (Review – Philadelphia Inquirer, June 20, 1999)
This CD provides a neat entrée into the slightly loopy and hard-swinging world of leader Joel Forrester. The composer of National Public Radio's Fresh Air theme and a cofounder of the now-defunct Microscopic Septet, pianist Forrester projects a slightly off-kilter style that manages to reach a torrid pace and express happiness at the same time.

This CD represents Forrester's last recording with Denis Charles, his longtime drummer, who died in March 1998. Baritone saxophonist Claire Daly bellows with burly conviction – her recent Koch CD Swing Low also showcases her considerable talents – while bassist Dave Hofstra provides ample bottom. Forrester, a native of the Pittsburgh suburb of Mount Lebanon, is a serious jazz guy. It's a bonus that he's a tad wacky.


Marcela Bretori, In Heaven (Review – Jazz Times, August 1999)
The influence of Monk is writ large here, but as Francis Davis writes in the liner notes, "Forrester's ability to suggest Thelonious Monk (is achieved) by winking allusion rather than shallow emulation." The eight numbers are composed by Forrester, and the quartet's playing is intelligent and engaging. On the longest number, "The Road Ahead", Claire Daly's rough tone on baritone and Forrester's bright and playful approach are characteristic of the stimulating musical conversations one hears on this excellent outing.


                   In Heaven (Review – JazzIz, Feb. 1999)
A little looser, yet quite similar, is In Heaven by People Like Us. The music's singularity stems from pianist-leader Joel Forrester's distinctive tunes. They should properly be called compositions – they're elaborate and rigorous enough to be deemed so. But there's an intrinsic congeniality to Forrester's writing for this band. It makes thoughtful, progressive improvising seem like the most joyous task around.

Hofstra's animated bass is also part of this band, which includes the late Denis Charles on drums, and baritone saxist Claire Daly. From the gleefully bent salutation, "Straight Ahead", to the infectious "Make Mine Music", the band gives the tunes a daft élan that suggests advanced ideas have many ways to avoid stuffiness.


Marcela Bretori, (Review – Jazz Times, August 1999)
The influence of Monk is writ large here, but as Francis Davis writes in the liner notes, "Forrester's ability to suggest Thelonious Monk (is achieved) by winking allusion rather than shallow emulation." The eight numbers are composed by Forrester, and the quartet's playing is intelligent and engaging. On the longest number, "The Road Ahead", Claire Daly's rough tone on baritone and Forrester's bright and playful approach are characteristic of the stimulating musical conversations one hears on this excellent outing.


Len Dobbin,(Len Dobbin, Montreal Mirror, Feb. 5, 1998) Joel Forrester's Stop the Music
Pianist Joel Forrester, best known for his work with the Microscopic Septet and now leader of People Like Us, makes his solo debut on this session from last February. All but two of the 13 cuts are Joel's and they are as quirky as his playing. Among them are a beauty of a ballad, "The Day That You Forgave Me," the boogie-flavoured "Back Talk" and the silent movie-inspired "Lunacy". Great listening! 9/10


David Prince,No…Really! (Review – Cadence ,Sept. 1997)
You can learn a lot from the fallout of failed marriages, political campaigns and cooperative musical entities alike. Fr'instance ,and despite the fact it took fifteen years to happen, the release of Walter Becker's admirable 11 Tracks of Wack (Giant, 1994) revealed that it was Becker (and not frontman Donald Fagan) who brought out the razored wit and blacken'd heart in Steely Dan, and that Don was merely the soft-centered, chordally sophisticated Fusioneer who gave laconic voice to Walter's cynical vision.

The similarly belated advent of "No…Really!" sheds insightful light on the composition, as it were, of the texturally unpredictable, colorful collaboration known throughout the length of their dozen-year, four-album existence as the Microscopic Sextet, which was created by P.L.U. pianist Forrester and current Big Trouble ringmaster, sopranist Phillip Johnston. The evidence of the present volume, which is Forrester's first as a leader, makes out a case that it was Johnston who brought the more lightly skewed perspective to the Micros, while it was the lyrical, precise Forrester who was content to be wildest around the edges.

Meaning ,I suppose that "No…Really!"'s true subversion lies in its utter accessibility and (no…really, I swear) potential widespread commercial appeal, to paraphrase the late Frank Zappa. The harmonically rich, nimble bebop People Like Us tosses off with such casual aplomb deserves thunderous applause followed by rapt attention. Who knows? We'll see.

No doubt partially due to the baritone saxophone's front-line dominance – Micro alum Dave Sewelson guests with the astounding Claire Daly)whose clean articulation places her a bit closer to Serge Chaloff than Jeru) on a trio of tracks – one can't help drawing allusional parallels between P.L.U. and that vintage, circa-1959, Gerry Mulligan/Art Farmer fo'tet, the piano's presence notwithstanding. Then again, perhaps it's the record's overall warmth, or Forrester's witty melodic sense (he being the author of all the group's material), or maybe it's the spirited group interplay.

Whatever it is, the lasting impression is of maturity and strength. There's not a weak link in the band's chain of command. The only thing that's diminished about drummer Denis Charles over the years are the number of letters in his name; bassist Dave Hofstra (yet another M. Septet holdover) is inventive, resonant and dependable; baritonist Daly is full of verve and technical skill, and leader Forrester roams his keyboard with subtle angularity and clever introspection played with delicate deftness alternating homage to his major inspiration, T.S. Monk (the father – or is that the Holy Spirit? In any case, not the son.)

About the only negative I can dredge up, tucked far away in a corner, is that I detect an occasional coyness in Forrester's writing. This album's "Your Political Movie" and "The Cop-Out" have that feel, but on the other hand, their titles may place their lines in the stylistic arena of another of Forrester's major musical directions of late (he also writes for NPR's Fresh Air), which consists of structuring real-time soundtracks to accompany vintage French silent films. No…really

People Like Us have given us people a fine, fine album.


                    No…Really! (Review – CMJ, May 5, 1997)
The low-register, gruff-textured baritone sax, like expensive scotch whiskey, is an acquired taste. That factor, combined with its size (compared with its tenor, alto and soprano counterparts, the baritone is cumbersome), explains why the bair gets short shrift on bandstands and recording studios. Because of the limited opportunities afforded the bari, the instrument has relatively few practitioners. Nonetheless, those who do play the bari, as their first horn, usually play it well.

Such is the case here. People Like Us is a neobop foursome led by pianist/composer Joel Forrester, co-founder of New York's delightfully quirky Microscopic Septet, together for 20 years.

His compatriots are Dave Hofstra, (another charter member of the Micros), drummer Denis Charles and baritonist Claire Daly; three of the nine selections, all penned by Forrester (who has a whopping 950 tunes to his credit), feature a second bari, Dave Sewelson. "Wait For The Word" and, especially, "Don't Ask Me Now" (both with two baris) are airplay-worthy and telling of the pianist's link to Thelonious Monk.

Forrester, interestingly, performed many private solo recitals for Monk during the master's later years. Having befriended Monk's friend and patron, the legendary Baroness Pannonica de Koenigswarter, Forrester was invited to play in her house, on a piano outside the room the reclusive Monk seldom left. "I think it was the Baroness' strategy," he related to CMJ, "that if I played long enough, with enough inspiration, Monk might come out of his room. I played some of his own music for him as he lay in bed, but he found that less interesting than my own music, which he encouraged….. The main criticism he offered me was through his opening and closing of the door."

Forrester is an uncanny individualist with abiding respect for, and keen knowledge about, the jazz masters who've preceded him. Check out the aforesaid cuts, along with the other two-bari track, "Two Sisters", on this briskly melodic platter full of smile-inducing solos.


Greg Robinson, No…Really! (Review – Jazz Times, Sept. 1997)
Pianist and composer Joel Forrester, 51, still pounds the pavement on a regular basis, hunting for gigs in restaurants and bars around New York. A bop-oriented player with a crisp attack who cites Thelonious Monk as his number-one influence, Forrester recently issued No…Really!, the first CD by his working quartet, People Like Us. The personnel includes baritone saxophonist Claire Daly, bassist Dave Hofstra, and drummer Denis Charles.

"No recorded music I've ever made will thrill me the way a band like that does when it's actually playing on the stand," comments Forrester, who adds that his tireless efforts to et work are not just born of economic necessity but are practically "a compulsion" with him. "We have played so much in New York over the last year that it's a snap to record. We just went in and treated the recording as if it were a date in a club."

The Pittsburgh-born Forrester is an uncompromising bandleader who takes no interest in performing standards, or any non-original music, for that matter. With more than 900 tunes to his credit – over 200 in the working repertoire – nor is he interested in being somebody's sideman. "I don't consider a composition actually completed until maybe a half-year of being played by the current band goes by," he reveals. "By then, it's been modified by the other people. That's why I try and work as much as I possibly can: because the stand is the only proving ground for my tunes."

Previously, Forrester spent 12 years with the Microscopic Septet, which he co-founded with Philip Johnston in 1981.


                   No…Really! (Review – Newsday Fanfare, Sunday, May 4, 1997)
The influence of Monk is writ large here, but as Francis Davis writes in the liner notes, "Forrester's ability to suggest Thelonious Monk (is achieved) by winking allusion rather than shallow emulation." The eight numbers are composed by Forrester, and the quartet's playing is intelligent and engaging. On the longest number, "The Road Ahead", Claire Daly's rough tone on baritone and Forrester's bright and playful approach are characteristic of the stimulating musical conversations one hears on this excellent outing.

Jazz is winning Pulitzer Prizes, grabbing the media's lapels, catching the roving eyes of foundations with $1,000 bills falling out of their pockets. Which is all very nice and thrilling and a boon to civilization as we know it. Yet, there are …how to put this?...qualms about this talk of resurgence and respectability and tradition.

I'm all for resurgence. But respectability implies a smoothing out of jazz' more unruly traditions. Its sense of humor, for instance.

Even those who pride themselves on being opposed to the grim guardians of tradition at Lincoln Center can be just as grim and, if anything, more humorless. Has everyone forgotten that jazz – exalted American treasure, timeless, majestic art and all that blah blah – is supposed to be fun?

People like Joel Forrester haven't. Forrester was the pianist and, along with Phillip Johnston, co-founder of the late, lamented Microscopic Septet, a cadre of rakish wise guys who played big-band music with cool finesse and antic daring. In a less confused, more generous world they might have been superstars. But they were always a little too "outside" for mainstream tastes and too raucous for the musical elite.

People Like Us, a Forrester-led quartet that includes Denis Charles on drums, Claire Daly on baritone sax and Dave Hofstra on bass, dose the same thing with small-group dynamics that the Microscopics did with big-band conventions: turn them inside out without shattering the format.

"Wait for the Word", for instance, flows like a Lennie Trestano arrangement, complete with unexpected harmonic shifts. "I Wonder" takes the listener on a winding journey through the rhumba at varying speeds. As was the case with the Microscopics, the quartet's music carries traits lacking in a lot of contemporary jazz: catchy melodies, zesty hooks and cool titles like "Monkey in the Middle" and "Your Political Movie." It's "trad-hop" that packs a seltzer bottle, ready t squirt your expectations silly.

People Like Us is an exuberant reply to those who think jazz takes itself either too seriously or not seriously enough. Yet, Forrester and company are so "fringe" that it'll take a miracle to convince bookers for "Rosie" or "Regis & Kathie Lee" to give this music some air time. C'mon, guys! The least you can do is read the liner notes. Forrester's dry, wry commentary will make you consider hiring him as a full-time comic foil. You could do a lot worse.